We welcome article submissions from experts in the areas of coal, mining,
shipping, etc.
To Submit your article please click here.
|
|
|
Monday, 31 August 20
DEFECTIVE PASSAGE PLANNING: UNSEAWORTHINESS OR A NAVIGATIONAL DECISION? THE CMA CGM LIBRA QUESTION SAILS ON TO THE UK SUPREME COURT - GARD
 KNOWLEDGE TO ELEVATE
The UK Supreme Court has granted leave to appeal the recent decision in Alize 1954 v Allianz Elementar Versicherungs AG (The “CMA CGM LIBRA”). While the decision involved General Average, we discuss the ramifications of the finding of unseaworthiness as it applies to the allocation of risk and liabilities in the wider context of the marine transport of goods.
International law aims to apportion risk in the transport of goods between the ship interests and cargo interests. Simply put, shipowners are responsible for cargo claims caused by unseaworthiness of the ship but are exempt from liability for cargo claims caused by certain risks, including navigational errors. The decision in Alize 1954 v Allianz Elementar Versicherungs AG (The “CMA CGM LIBRA”) [2020] EWCA Civ 293 shifts the established boundary between what is considered “seaworthiness” and “navigation” resulting in shipowners bearing a greater portion of the risk of the adventure. While the CMA CGM LIBRA case involved General Average, it comes as no surprise that decision led to an increase in claims by cargo interests alleging unseaworthiness on the basis of navigational decisions. The vessel owners recently obtained permission to appeal the decision to the UK Supreme Court and the International Group of P&I Clubs supports the vessel owners’ position.
Background to the case
On 17 May 2011, M/V “CMA CGM LIBRA”, a 6,000 TEU container ship, grounded while leaving the port of Xiamen, China. The ship’s charts had failed to record a warning derived from a Notice to Mariners that depths shown on the chart outside the fairway were unreliable and waters were shallower than recorded on the chart. The grounding occurred when the master sailed the vessel outside of the fairway, expecting the waters to be deeper than they actually were. The owners claimed general average contributions from the cargo interests.
The first instance judgment
In Teare J’s first instance decision dated 8 March 2019, he held that the passage plan and working charts were defective due to the failure to record the warning required by the Notice to Mariners, and these defects rendered the vessel unseaworthy at the commencement of the voyage. The owners’ claims were therefore dismissed.
The first instance decision gave rise to significant controversy in maritime law circles. Some commentators held the view that the decision confused issues of unseaworthiness with issues of navigation. They argued that the preparation of passage plans is a matter of navigation, the neglect of which would entitle a carrier to defences under Article IV Rule 2(a) of the Hague or Hague-Visby Rules. By considering passage planning as falling within the orbit of seaworthiness rather than navigation, the court is disrupting the well-established division of risk between the ship and cargo. It has also been commented that applying a strictly temporal approach, i.e. that all acts or omissions prior to the commencement of the voyage relate to seaworthiness may have wider implication to re-distributing risk between the ship and cargo than the question of passage planning.
Other commentators saw the decision as a correct application of principles concerning a carrier’s duties in respect of seaworthiness, based on the traditional definition of seaworthiness laid down in McFadden v Blue Star Line (1905): “Would a prudent owner have required that [the relevant defect] should be made good before sending his ship to sea, had he known of it? If he would, the ship was not seaworthy.” On this view, given that no prudent shipowner would knowingly send his vessel to sea with a defective passage plan and defective charts that had not been properly updated, these commentators argued that it therefore follows that the vessel was not seaworthy at the commencement of the voyage.
The Court of Appeal decision
The first instance judgment was appealed, and for a time, it seemed that the controversy had been resolved following the handing down of the Court of Appeal’s judgment on 4 March 2020. In a unanimous decision by a 3-member panel of experienced shipping judges, the Court of Appeal upheld the first instance judgment. The Court confirmed that errors in navigation or management can render a vessel unseaworthy if they occur prior to the commencement of the voyage. The Court rejected the vessel owners’ argument that the passage plan and working chart were not “attributes of the ship”, but records of navigational decisions taken by the crew.
The Court also found that once the owners assumed responsibility for the cargo as the carrier, all acts of the master and crew in preparing the vessel for the voyage (even if they are acts of navigation performed before or at the commencement of the voyage) are performed qua carrier and not qua navigator. Thus, the owners are responsible for all such acts, and the crew’s failure to exercise due diligence to make the vessel seaworthy would be imputed to the owners.
Leave to appeal to the Supreme Court
In late July 2020, the owners obtained permission to appeal the Court of Appeal’s decision to the UK Supreme Court. The owners’ position remains that the crew’s decision as to what to mark on the chart was a navigational decision rather than an “attribute of the ship” and was therefore not an issue of seaworthiness. It is anticipated that the appeal will take place in late 2021.
Concluding comments
Given the importance of this case regarding the allocation of risk between ship and cargo in a maritime adventure, the International Group of P&I Clubs welcome the UK Supreme Court’s decision to hear the case, and has backed the application made seeking leave to appeal to the Supreme court. Gard will continue to provide updates on developments in this case as they unfold.
Source: Gard
If you believe an article violates your rights or the rights of others, please contact us.
|
|
Wednesday, 21 June 23
CHINA'S MAY COAL IMPORTS FROM AUSTRALIA RECOVER TO PRE-BAN LEVELS - REUTERS
Australian coal sales to China increased in May, as trade resumed between them even as overall coal demand weakened against an uncertain macroecono ...
Monday, 19 June 23
DROUGHT-DEPLETED HYDROPOWER DRIVES CHINA TO TURN TO COAL - REUTERS
China has leant hard on coal-fired power plants as well as wind and solar generators to make up for a shortfall in hydroelectric generation as a re ...
Monday, 19 June 23
CHINA COAL OUTPUT UP 4.2 PCT IN MAY - XINHUA
China’s raw coal output posted steady growth in May, official data showed.
The country produced 390 million tonnes of raw coal ...
Wednesday, 24 May 23
AMMONIA-FUELLED BULK CARRIERS WITHIN FIVE YEARS - BALTIC EXCHANGE
Within five years, ships powered by clean ammonia could be a feature on the iron ore trade routes between West Australia and East Asia.
A study ...
Tuesday, 23 May 23
CHINA'S APRIL COAL OUTPUT LEAPS 11% ON YEAR, BUT DEMAND DOWNTURN LOOMS - REUTERS
China’s daily coal output in April jumped 11% from the same month a year earlier, boosted by Beijing’s order to increase supply to ensu ...
|
|
|
Showing 96 to 100 news of total 6871 |
|
 |
|
|
|
|
| |
|
 |
|
|
| |
|
- Singapore Mercantile Exchange
- Cement Manufacturers Association - India
- Price Waterhouse Coopers - Russia
- Bhushan Steel Limited - India
- Dalmia Cement Bharat India
- Parliament of New Zealand
- CIMB Investment Bank - Malaysia
- Anglo American - United Kingdom
- Thiess Contractors Indonesia
- Leighton Contractors Pty Ltd - Australia
- Bulk Trading Sa - Switzerland
- Iligan Light & Power Inc, Philippines
- Holcim Trading Pte Ltd - Singapore
- TNB Fuel Sdn Bhd - Malaysia
- Australian Commodity Traders Exchange
- GVK Power & Infra Limited - India
- Latin American Coal - Colombia
- Vizag Seaport Private Limited - India
- Meralco Power Generation, Philippines
- Antam Resourcindo - Indonesia
- White Energy Company Limited
- Heidelberg Cement - Germany
- Bukit Baiduri Energy - Indonesia
- Dr Ramakrishna Prasad Power Pvt Ltd - India
- Banpu Public Company Limited - Thailand
- Indian Oil Corporation Limited
- Samtan Co., Ltd - South Korea
- Savvy Resources Ltd - HongKong
- GMR Energy Limited - India
- Orica Australia Pty. Ltd.
- Truba Alam Manunggal Engineering.Tbk - Indonesia
- San Jose City I Power Corp, Philippines
- Jorong Barutama Greston.PT - Indonesia
- Bukit Makmur.PT - Indonesia
- Jindal Steel & Power Ltd - India
- Mercuria Energy - Indonesia
- Global Green Power PLC Corporation, Philippines
- Commonwealth Bank - Australia
- Deloitte Consulting - India
- Maheswari Brothers Coal Limited - India
- Trasteel International SA, Italy
- Bukit Asam (Persero) Tbk - Indonesia
- GAC Shipping (India) Pvt Ltd
- Makarim & Taira - Indonesia
- Ambuja Cements Ltd - India
- Larsen & Toubro Limited - India
- Kideco Jaya Agung - Indonesia
- International Coal Ventures Pvt Ltd - India
- Asmin Koalindo Tuhup - Indonesia
- Port Waratah Coal Services - Australia
- McConnell Dowell - Australia
- Alfred C Toepfer International GmbH - Germany
- Pipit Mutiara Jaya. PT, Indonesia
- Chamber of Mines of South Africa
- Globalindo Alam Lestari - Indonesia
- Metalloyd Limited - United Kingdom
- PetroVietnam Power Coal Import and Supply Company
- Intertek Mineral Services - Indonesia
- VISA Power Limited - India
- India Bulls Power Limited - India
- Edison Trading Spa - Italy
- SN Aboitiz Power Inc, Philippines
- Minerals Council of Australia
- Sindya Power Generating Company Private Ltd
- Indian Energy Exchange, India
- Grasim Industreis Ltd - India
- Mjunction Services Limited - India
- Karbindo Abesyapradhi - Indoneisa
- AsiaOL BioFuels Corp., Philippines
- Petrochimia International Co. Ltd.- Taiwan
- SMC Global Power, Philippines
- MS Steel International - UAE
- Bhoruka Overseas - Indonesia
- Mintek Dendrill Indonesia
- Neyveli Lignite Corporation Ltd, - India
- Tamil Nadu electricity Board
- Indogreen Group - Indonesia
- Kumho Petrochemical, South Korea
- Ceylon Electricity Board - Sri Lanka
- Indonesian Coal Mining Association
- Kohat Cement Company Ltd. - Pakistan
- Billiton Holdings Pty Ltd - Australia
- GN Power Mariveles Coal Plant, Philippines
- Mercator Lines Limited - India
- Malabar Cements Ltd - India
- Offshore Bulk Terminal Pte Ltd, Singapore
- Interocean Group of Companies - India
- Directorate General of MIneral and Coal - Indonesia
- Straits Asia Resources Limited - Singapore
- London Commodity Brokers - England
- Global Business Power Corporation, Philippines
- Filglen & Citicon Mining (HK) Ltd - Hong Kong
- Meenaskhi Energy Private Limited - India
- Altura Mining Limited, Indonesia
- ASAPP Information Group - India
- Global Coal Blending Company Limited - Australia
- The University of Queensland
- Asia Pacific Energy Resources Ventures Inc, Philippines
- Essar Steel Hazira Ltd - India
- Sical Logistics Limited - India
- Planning Commission, India
- Ministry of Finance - Indonesia
- Timah Investasi Mineral - Indoneisa
- Borneo Indobara - Indonesia
- PTC India Limited - India
- Kepco SPC Power Corporation, Philippines
- Miang Besar Coal Terminal - Indonesia
- Independent Power Producers Association of India
- Marubeni Corporation - India
- OPG Power Generation Pvt Ltd - India
- Bharathi Cement Corporation - India
- Toyota Tsusho Corporation, Japan
- Jaiprakash Power Ventures ltd
- Directorate Of Revenue Intelligence - India
- Kobexindo Tractors - Indoneisa
- Bangladesh Power Developement Board
- Central Electricity Authority - India
- Baramulti Group, Indonesia
- Binh Thuan Hamico - Vietnam
- Riau Bara Harum - Indonesia
- Wilmar Investment Holdings
- Ind-Barath Power Infra Limited - India
- Australian Coal Association
- Attock Cement Pakistan Limited
- Romanian Commodities Exchange
- Energy Link Ltd, New Zealand
- Bhatia International Limited - India
- Vijayanagar Sugar Pvt Ltd - India
- Orica Mining Services - Indonesia
- Economic Council, Georgia
- Manunggal Multi Energi - Indonesia
- Agrawal Coal Company - India
- Gujarat Mineral Development Corp Ltd - India
- Eastern Coal Council - USA
- Georgia Ports Authority, United States
- Dong Bac Coal Mineral Investment Coporation - Vietnam
- The State Trading Corporation of India Ltd
- Siam City Cement PLC, Thailand
- Salva Resources Pvt Ltd - India
- Xindia Steels Limited - India
- Merrill Lynch Commodities Europe
- Sojitz Corporation - Japan
- Wood Mackenzie - Singapore
- Energy Development Corp, Philippines
- Cigading International Bulk Terminal - Indonesia
- Coal and Oil Company - UAE
- Barasentosa Lestari - Indonesia
- Sakthi Sugars Limited - India
- Aditya Birla Group - India
- Bayan Resources Tbk. - Indonesia
- TeaM Sual Corporation - Philippines
- Posco Energy - South Korea
- Renaissance Capital - South Africa
- Coastal Gujarat Power Limited - India
- Karaikal Port Pvt Ltd - India
- Rio Tinto Coal - Australia
- Electricity Generating Authority of Thailand
- Sarangani Energy Corporation, Philippines
- Bahari Cakrawala Sebuku - Indonesia
- IEA Clean Coal Centre - UK
- Indika Energy - Indonesia
- Aboitiz Power Corporation - Philippines
- PowerSource Philippines DevCo
- Lanco Infratech Ltd - India
- Petron Corporation, Philippines
- Kaltim Prima Coal - Indonesia
- Kartika Selabumi Mining - Indonesia
- Maharashtra Electricity Regulatory Commission - India
- Siam City Cement - Thailand
- SMG Consultants - Indonesia
- Semirara Mining Corp, Philippines
- ICICI Bank Limited - India
- Oldendorff Carriers - Singapore
- New Zealand Coal & Carbon
- IHS Mccloskey Coal Group - USA
- Standard Chartered Bank - UAE
- European Bulk Services B.V. - Netherlands
- CNBM International Corporation - China
- Therma Luzon, Inc, Philippines
- Sinarmas Energy and Mining - Indonesia
- Pendopo Energi Batubara - Indonesia
- Krishnapatnam Port Company Ltd. - India
- Videocon Industries ltd - India
- Parry Sugars Refinery, India
- Formosa Plastics Group - Taiwan
- Tata Chemicals Ltd - India
- Power Finance Corporation Ltd., India
- Kalimantan Lumbung Energi - Indonesia
- Gujarat Electricity Regulatory Commission - India
- Coalindo Energy - Indonesia
- South Luzon Thermal Energy Corporation
- Uttam Galva Steels Limited - India
- Carbofer General Trading SA - India
- Vedanta Resources Plc - India
- Ministry of Mines - Canada
- Africa Commodities Group - South Africa
- Madhucon Powers Ltd - India
- Rashtriya Ispat Nigam Limited - India
- Gujarat Sidhee Cement - India
- Indo Tambangraya Megah - Indonesia
- Medco Energi Mining Internasional
- Ministry of Transport, Egypt
- Electricity Authority, New Zealand
- Star Paper Mills Limited - India
- The Treasury - Australian Government
- LBH Netherlands Bv - Netherlands
- Central Java Power - Indonesia
- Thai Mozambique Logistica
- Sree Jayajothi Cements Limited - India
- Kapuas Tunggal Persada - Indonesia
- Semirara Mining and Power Corporation, Philippines
- Chettinad Cement Corporation Ltd - India
- Goldman Sachs - Singapore
- PNOC Exploration Corporation - Philippines
- Eastern Energy - Thailand
- Simpson Spence & Young - Indonesia
- Bank of Tokyo Mitsubishi UFJ Ltd
|
| |
| |
|
